Let's Talk About Respect For Each Other, Dear Fans Of "Treasure Island" By David Cherkassky

Let's talk about respect for each other, dear fans of "Treasure Island" by David Cherkassky

(although I recommend that other fans of the film/cartoon adaptations of Robert Louis Stevenson's novel join in).

Before I start talking about the problem in the Russian fandom of Treasure Island 1988, I want to say: I am Russian too and I am writing this not because I am an offended foreigner, but because I am ashamed of you all (this is a message to the fanatics works of Cherkassky).

The fact is that I noticed one interesting detail that helps to distinguish the Russian Internet from the English one. On the English-speaking internet, I feel comfortable saying that I like Takarajima because I know that most people will react either positively or neutrally. But on the Russian-language Internet, I need to conduct a fairly long search to find a person who will not judge me for loving anime. On the Russian Internet, treating someone neutrally or respectfully is considered a new fashion...

Let's Talk About Respect For Each Other, Dear Fans Of "Treasure Island" By David Cherkassky

I don’t feel like I’m part of the Russian-speaking fans of the 1988 film adaptation, since I also love other film adaptations of Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel. And this is... strange, because in theory we should share our love for various cartoons and films, and not beat those who love other works or are afraid of being beaten.

I have often come across the opinion that David Cherkassky is a genius and that only his version of Treasure Island is correct. I've often read that fans of 1988's Treasure Island think other adaptations from other countries are weird. I have often come across the opinion that there is only one correct and good film adaptation of Stevenson’s novel.

And I'm sick of it all.

Man who is over thirty years old and who calls children idiots for unfunny memes about your favorite cartoon, I am addressing you and others like you. I appeal to all those who cannot see what even blind Pew would see.

THERE IS NO CORRECT OR IDEAL FILM OR CARTOON ADAPTATION OF "TREASURE ISLAND"!

In the entire history of cinema, there has never been a perfect adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson's novel that everyone liked.

And now I will prove it:

The 1965 adaptation may seem strange in terms of plot, instead of people it's all animals, and the ending is different from the ending of the original story;

The 1971 adaptation left virtually nothing of the original story;

The 1978 adaptation often deviates from the canonical development of events in order to stretch the runtime over twenty-odd episodes;

Treasure Planet 1982 is a drug trip for everyone who worked on this cartoon (the budget for this cartoon is three packs of cocaine and marijuana, I'm sure of it);

The 1988 adaptation is a comedy based on the novel, which did not include enough characters (for example, Jim's parents remained somewhere off-screen) and events;

Legends of Treasure Island (1993) is a mystery series where events from Stevenson's novel appear less and less as the series progresses;

The 2002 DVD adaptation is not particularly pleasing with its cheap animation and character reactions (some people find the film adaptation rather boring and faded);

Treasure Planet 2002 may not appeal to some due to the space setting and decisions related to the characters (for example, not everyone will appreciate the fact that Smollett became an alien catwoman and that Livesey and Trelawney were combined into one character) and plot.

However, all these cartoon adaptations also have advantages:

The 1965 adaptation has an interesting twist on how predators have to hide their real selves. I'm talking about claws and how they have to fight the urge to walk on two legs. This also explains why the bones in the chest are treasure to them;

What may be interesting about the 1971 adaptation is that it deviates greatly from the original book;

The 1978 adaptation boasts beautiful stills that you wouldn't be ashamed to frame on your wall, and a soundtrack that might make some people cry ("Oh yes, yes! Play that violin even harder! I want to hear all your skill in this composition!! Ah~");

1982's Treasure Planet appeals to some people precisely because it's quite weird. “So bad it’s good” is how you can describe it. Character design and weird animation can also come in (I like Jim);

People like the 1988 adaptation due to the ease of storytelling, fun and vivid images of characters that you will not be able to forget. I also like it because it teaches the right things, for example, they say that smoking and drinking are harmful to human health (thanks to these songs, I don’t consider smoking and drinking alcohol something cool);

Legends of Treasure Island 1993 can help people relive their innocent childhood and forget about reality for a while. There are violent moments and interesting plot developments that are fun to follow;

The 2002 adaptation follows the book almost exactly. Jim is still a good boy and he, like the others, is not annoying (considering the quality of the picture, this could have happened, but did not);

Treasure Planet 2002 is interesting to watch, at least because it combined the 18th century and the theme of space. Because of this idea, we have a unique product about space, which is unique among all others. As a person who doesn’t like the theme of space because of monotony (the theme of modernity in any work is not interesting to me, just like the future), I admit that wooden ships in space captivated me.

And this is without even mentioning the other cartoons and films based on the book (and there are a lot of them)! But I think that it has already become clear to you that everywhere and in all film adaptations, in addition to the bad, there is also good. I know I haven't talked about Treasure Island from the Muppets or McDonald's, but the fact is that I haven't watched them yet. I'll definitely watch everything!

However, my goal was not to talk about all the film adaptations of my favorite book - my goal was to show that you can find at least one more film adaptation of Treasure Island that you like.

However, my goal was not to talk about all the film adaptations of my favorite book - my goal was to show that you can find at least one more film adaptation of Treasure Island that you like.

And before I finish writing this post, I want to offer you three simple rules that, if followed, can reconcile fans of different “Treasure Islands” (I hope they'll work).

And these three rules sound like this:

1) Read the original novel by Robert Louis Stevenson (not a summary, not a short version of the book, but the whole story);

2) Watch other cartoons and films based on the book and find those film adaptations that you like to talk about;

3) Treat other fans of the book and/or any other film adaptation with respect if they behave appropriately.

That's all, dear readers. Thank you for reading my post. You can safely express your opinion in the comments, I just ask you to write calmly and adequately. What's your favorite Treasure Island adaptation? What other cartoon or anime do I not know about?

Let's Talk About Respect For Each Other, Dear Fans Of "Treasure Island" By David Cherkassky

More Posts from Penguinwhowanttobeanartist and Others

TITLE IS TITLE

Do you think it's worth posting your drawings here as a… Challenge? Then to see how my skill grows?

If you have seen such things, then please send it to me.

I need a hug. I'm not sad or something like this... I just need a hug

I hope I don't regret it…

It's just two little sketches.

Just a silly young man who is actually a very good boy.

I Hope I Don't Regret It…

"Strict daddy calms down his best friend watch online without sms and registration."

I Hope I Don't Regret It…

Tags

I tried to drew him and...

I Tried To Drew Him And...

I DID IT!!!!!

HIS FACE LOOKS NORMAL!!!!

THANK YOU, NOW I CAN DRAW HIM AND HE'LL LOOKS GOOD!!!!

/Penguin screams because of happiness/

And how to draw 1977 Thradui..l? I'm sorry, if I ask a lot of questions...

Okay, I had to practice myself first, because I am not used to drawing the skrunklies.

image

I want to make some kind of horror, but I'm not good at making scary videos. If scary videos are posted here that are poorly made, I apologize in advance. I am just learning.

Those who can draw Livesey from the 1978 anime, please draw him with Jim. People miss the cute drawings of Livesey's paternal love for Jim! (I mean paternal love, not romantic!!!)


Tags
This Is My First Meme

This is my first meme

I'm not good at it, but I liked to made this meme


Tags
I Think That Boris Habit Speaks Russian Well (without Any Mistakes) Cuz He Is From Russia.

I think that Boris Habit speaks Russian well (without any mistakes) cuz he is from Russia.

Oh, there is what he said: "Kamal, you are my most beloved and closest person. You are the light in my life. I am grateful to you for everything, everything, everything. You are the best."

And "oх" means "oh"!


Tags

Okay, it turns out I'm on time...

So, since this is my first art-challenge, the quality of the drawings will vary "":^

Number one:

O/C in childhood

Okay, It Turns Out I'm On Time...

This is a sketch, don't be too harsh please...

Number two:

O/C with short or long hair

Okay, It Turns Out I'm On Time...

My original O/C has longer hair.

The fact is that I wanted to draw something good, but it is difficult to do it on the phone. WITH FINGERS!!!!!

Ok, it was joke. In reality I draw this:

Okay, It Turns Out I'm On Time...

I will no longer draw on the phone... I will draw only on paper, black pen and black felt-tip pen.

New "art" will be soon


Tags

I wanted to translate the opening of "Takarajima" into Latvian, but the problem is that the words in Latvian are longer than in Japanese. And I only managed to write the end… Help me

"Man ir tikai vienā vēlme un to neviens un nekad neatņems"


Tags
Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • lethargy-73
    lethargy-73 liked this · 2 months ago
  • lifeisreblogs
    lifeisreblogs liked this · 6 months ago
  • whydontyouliveadam
    whydontyouliveadam liked this · 7 months ago
  • crueee
    crueee liked this · 1 year ago
  • coronakoffee
    coronakoffee liked this · 1 year ago
  • dorie-knight1088
    dorie-knight1088 liked this · 1 year ago
  • pinkymachina
    pinkymachina liked this · 1 year ago
  • salmabunny
    salmabunny liked this · 1 year ago
  • nihalandbihter-joandamy
    nihalandbihter-joandamy liked this · 1 year ago
  • riku-hawkins
    riku-hawkins liked this · 1 year ago
  • maslo-margarin
    maslo-margarin liked this · 1 year ago
  • tsureggy
    tsureggy liked this · 1 year ago
  • scadaddletime
    scadaddletime liked this · 1 year ago
  • orionapraxnia
    orionapraxnia reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • orionapraxnia
    orionapraxnia liked this · 1 year ago
  • penguinwhowanttobeanartist
    penguinwhowanttobeanartist reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • penguinwhowanttobeanartist
    penguinwhowanttobeanartist reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • penguinwhowanttobeanartist
    penguinwhowanttobeanartist reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • princesskwaii
    princesskwaii liked this · 1 year ago
  • admirals-fleet
    admirals-fleet liked this · 1 year ago
  • asapmy
    asapmy reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • asapmy
    asapmy liked this · 1 year ago
  • undertheroses
    undertheroses liked this · 1 year ago
  • kalamitis
    kalamitis reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • kalamitis
    kalamitis liked this · 1 year ago
  • valerykurchubash
    valerykurchubash liked this · 1 year ago
  • candysnowfell
    candysnowfell liked this · 1 year ago
  • stargazinyx
    stargazinyx liked this · 1 year ago
  • crookeddesigncomicshoagie
    crookeddesigncomicshoagie liked this · 1 year ago
  • askpabit
    askpabit liked this · 1 year ago
  • acolorboom
    acolorboom liked this · 1 year ago
  • badcopslovingwife
    badcopslovingwife reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • badcopslovingwife
    badcopslovingwife liked this · 1 year ago
  • twilight-kira
    twilight-kira liked this · 1 year ago
  • redrat-cheesy
    redrat-cheesy liked this · 1 year ago
  • poni-poki
    poni-poki liked this · 1 year ago
  • franpun
    franpun liked this · 1 year ago
  • wolfdad
    wolfdad liked this · 1 year ago
  • hinazakuro
    hinazakuro liked this · 1 year ago
  • kailiberarts
    kailiberarts liked this · 1 year ago
penguinwhowanttobeanartist - Pingwine/Pingvīns
Pingwine/Pingvīns

One of the worst decisions of a young artist is to open an account on the Internet. As you can see, I make bad decisions.

24 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags