Character Thoughts - Elwing

I don’t think that Elwing throwing herself into the ocean had anything to do with possessiveness about the Silmaril. For me, it recalls two other scenes in Tolkien’s work.

One is Frodo’s defiance at the Ford of Bruinen: “By Elbereth and Lúthien the Fair, you shall have neither the Ring nor me!” A desperate defiance against evil when you’re at the end of your rope and the end of your strength (and retreat to water, and unexpected rescue).

And the other, even more strongly, is the Fall of Fingolfin. She’s just lost a desperate battle; she sees everything she knows and loves and has built falling into ruin and fire; she can’t stop any of it. But she can fight the people who did this to her, and she can hurt them, even if it kills her. She can’t outright duel Maedhros (he’s been probably the greatest swordsman in Beleriand for ten times longer than she’s been alive; that would quite possibly be a more unequal fight than the Duel of Fingolfin and Morgoth), but she still has a way to hurt him. You don’t get the Silmaril, and you don’t get to kill me. You don’t get to win.

The central thought underlying it is not ‘mine’; it is ‘fuck you’.

It is not about her keeping the Silmaril; it is about the Fëanorians not getting it.

I don’t think she knows just how well she’s succeeding at hurting them - everything in her life tells her the Fëanorians are monsters as bad as or worse than anything from Angband, not beings capable of remorse - but she knows she’s denying them the one thing they want. And Maedhros and Maglor are left knowing that the worst thing they’ve ever done was, as far as their goals are concerned, completely pointless.

She’s not ‘abandoning her children’. She’s already lost her children. She has no way to save them. She has no reason to believe they would be spared, whatever she did. The twins are of no use to the Fëanorians. The Fëanorians have already shown themselves willing to murder children, her brothers, that actually did have value as hostages. If Elwing handed over the Silmaril there’s no reason for her to believe they wouldn’t just kill her and her children for spite.

It can’t be emphasized enough that the Fëanorians are the monsters of Elwing’s life. Angband is a distant name and a threat. The murderers of Elwing’s father, her mother, her brothers, the twice-destroyers of her home, are the Fëanorians. They are her Morgoth.

Tags

silmarillion elwing

More Posts from Aroacebaggins and Others

aroacebaggins

3 weeks ago

We all know that Halenthir has impeccable vibes, but no one can convince me that Haleth isn't a raging lesbian. Luckily, there's an obvious solution to this problem: transfem Caranthir. In this essay I will-

Tags

lesbian lgbtqia my post transgender silmarillion tolkien allo nonsense there is no essay my justification is i said so halenthir caranthir haleth carnistir feanorians silm ramblings

14 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

3 weeks ago

Late 1st Age Noldor: We've made a king :)

Círdan: You've ruined a perfectly good child is what you did. Look at him. He has anxiety.

Tags

silmarillion tolkien gil galad cirdan

95 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

2 weeks ago

Maybe Turgon chose to follow his family to cross the Ice partially because his daughter kept having dreams of 'Tirion' getting destroyed in fire

(After Gondolin was built Idril would one day look at the city from some tower and went "oh no")

Tags

silmarillion tolkien oh nooo turgon idril idril celebrindal gondolin

294 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

3 weeks ago

hot take but “it’s perfectly fine to portray aspec characters as having sex/dating bc aspec people still do those things” and “fandom often overwhelmingly portrays aspec characters as having sex/dating with little to no regard for their aspec identity, leaving little room for aspecs who don’t do those things” are two statements that can and should coexist

Tags

lgbtqia asexual ace aromantic we really just need more aspec characters overall because i do want to see all the variety

42 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

2 weeks ago

2 other things i really love from this translation of finrod song battle!!!

1) the use of "a lo lejos" (far away) to describe nargothrond, and in the next line the use of "mucho más lejos" (much farther away) to describe the western sea. it feels to me like an emphasis on how far from home finrod is in this moment. its very bittersweet to me

2) "EL VIENTO SE LAMENTA" FOR "THE WIND WAILS." ALSJAKDHSHJAH. ok let me explain. this is the first phrase following the description of the kinslaying at alqualondë. yes lamentarse can technically be translated as to wail but it also has an obvious connection to lament, regret, grief, and so on. much more powerful i think in this context (probably not intentional but i could also connect this to manwë mourning the fall of the noldor and the slaying of the teleri...... just saying)

Tags

spanish silmarillion tolkien the second one is so cool dang i need to do this at some point i'm currently struggling through el hobbit so i am not ready for the silm in spanish yet but i love bilbo bolson

6 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

2 weeks ago

Part: 133/?

Tags

hahaha the rings of power elrond trop celebrimbor elrond peredhel trop crack trop memes rop crack

280 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

3 weeks ago

me when my disabilities disable me:

Tags

chronic illness chronically ill disability disabled i love ignoring my limitations until the next morning when i am hit full force with the consequences all because i had the audacity to do activities

32K notes View Post

aroacebaggins

2 weeks ago

Rings of Power meme dump part 11!!

Edit: Oops meant to schedule this one. I guess there's two today lol. Also I can't count.

Tags

my post gandalf the rings of power sauron elrond halbrand trop celebrimbor galadriel elrond peredhel trop crack trop memes rop crack ringsofpowerdaily my trop memes annatar durin iv isildur ar pharazon gil galad

14 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

2 weeks ago

i cannot understate how much i adore what andor has done for mon mothma. the way this show has taken someone who before this was mostly neglected to small supporting roles, and turned her into one of the most layered, complex and tragic characters in all of star wars has absolutely floured me, not to mention how BRILLIANT genevieve o’reilly’s performance has been too 🙏

Tags

star wars andor mon mothma

354 notes View Post

aroacebaggins

3 weeks ago

Rings of Power meme dump part 5!

I didn't have all these files anymore so I had to go get them from my Pinterest, the first image got a little cut off for some reason sorry.

Tags

my post the rings of power elrond celebrimbor galadriel elrond peredhel trop crack trop memes rop crack ringsofpowerdaily my trop memes isildur gil galad elendil lotr on prime cirdan

30 notes View Post

End of content

No more pages to load